• Home
  • What Bitcoin's Quieter Trading Reveals About Borrowed Bets and Fed Policy
What Bitcoin's Quieter Trading Reveals About Borrowed Bets and Fed Policy
By Dana Jerlo profile image Dana Jerlo
3 min read

What Bitcoin's Quieter Trading Reveals About Borrowed Bets and Fed Policy

When a Bitcoin price drop turns into a sharp fall, it is often because someone was forced to sell, not because they chose to. That is what a leverage wipeout looks like. Traders who bought with borrowed money have a line where the lender or trading platform closes their position automatically. Once enough of those lines are crossed at once, the selling feeds itself. Each forced sale pushes the price lower, which triggers the next group of forced sales.

After a wave like that, the market often goes quiet. Bitcoin has settled into what traders call sideways trading, meaning the price moves up and down inside a fairly tight range without a clear direction. Some of that calm comes from the fact that many of the most stretched borrowers have already been cleared out. Some comes from waiting.

Why the Fed matters more than the Bank of Canada here

Bitcoin is priced around the world in U.S. dollars, so the U.S. Federal Reserve has more pull on it than our own central bank does. When the Fed signals it will hold rates steady, money that might have gone into higher-risk bets has less reason to move. A savings account, a GIC or a short-term bond still pays a reasonable return with very little risk. When that safer option pays well, a volatile asset like Bitcoin has to work harder to attract buyers.

That is why speculative trading has slowed. Investors are waiting to see whether rate cuts actually arrive or whether rates stay higher for longer. A quiet market in that setting is a pause, not a recovery. The price has stopped falling for now, but nothing about a calm stretch rules out another swing. Lower rates usually help assets like Bitcoin, though even that is not a sure thing. If the economy weakens badly, cheaper borrowing may not be enough to bring people back to risky bets.

Where this meets a mortgage

I spend my days in Edmonton helping people borrow against homes, so the part of this story I watch most closely is the borrowed money. The Bitcoin market just showed, in a very public way, what happens when an asset drops while the debt used to buy it stays the same.

The same thing can happen on a smaller scale with a home equity line of credit, or HELOC, which is a loan secured against the value of your house. If you draw on it to buy Bitcoin and the price falls by a third, you do not owe a third less. You still owe the full amount, at a rate that moves with the prime rate. Your home is the security behind that debt.

There is also a tax point people often miss. Under Canadian tax rules, interest on borrowed money is generally deductible only when the money is used to earn income such as dividends, interest or rent, and there has to be a reasonable expectation of that income. Interest on money borrowed to earn rental income, for example, is deductible under section 20(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act. Bitcoin pays no dividend or rent. If the only hope is that the price goes up, that is a capital gain, and the interest on the loan usually is not deductible. A rental property bought with the same borrowed dollars sits in a very different place.

Timing matters too. If you are saving for a down payment, or setting money aside for a business expense in the next six to twelve months, Bitcoin is a hard place to keep it. The recent swings showed how quickly prices can move and how fast buyers can disappear. A down payment that shrinks right before closing can change what you qualify for, or whether the purchase goes ahead at all.

Interest rate changes also take time to work through the economy. The Bank of Canada estimates the lag at 18 to 24 months. So even if rates start moving lower, the effect on household budgets, home prices and investor appetite arrives slowly, not on the day of the announcement.

For anyone in Alberta who does decide to hold crypto, the Alberta Securities Commission oversees the trading platforms operating in the province and publishes investor alerts about firms that are not registered. Checking a platform there before sending money is a simple step.

Holding Bitcoin alongside a large mortgage is a concentrated position. Both depend heavily on where interest rates go. The quiet trading we are seeing now is a good moment to look at how much of your plan rests on borrowed money, and how it would hold up if prices moved against you before rates move in your favour.